Home|TOC|Previous|Next  

Meta Science in the News


First galaxies formed quickly? Or not.

            Astronomers have used deep-sky searches to examine the farthest galaxies, and found many examples near redshift 6. However, very few were found between redshifts 7-8, even allowing for added faintness. The conclusion drawn was that galaxy formation in the early Big Bang universe set in quite suddenly about 13 billion years ago.


            But as is well known, galaxies tend to occur in great walls separated by vast voids. Moreover, certain redshift values are consistently seen more frequently than others in high-redshift surveys. One of those peaks falls somewhat above redshift 6, and one of the voids falls between redshifts 7-8. So this interpretation is specious unless it can be shown that there is no prevalence of galaxies at the next redshift peak outward. Perhaps the next generation Space Telescope will have the capability to see these or to establish their absence.


NASA’s Stardust mission may alter view of comet formation

Samples from comet Wild 2 have surprised scientists, who have found minerals formed near the sun or other stars in the samples returned to Earth by NASA's Stardust spacecraft in January. The findings suggest materials from the center of the solar system could have traveled to the outer reaches where comets formed. This may alter the way scientists view the formation and composition of comets. High-temperature minerals are found in materials from the coldest place in the solar system. This supports a particular model where strong bipolar jets coming out of the early sun propelled material formed near to the sun outward to the outer reaches of the solar system. One mineral found in the material brought back by Stardust is olivine, a primary component of the green sand found on some Hawaiian beaches (because it is ejected by volcanoes from deep in Earth’s interior). Olivine is a compound of iron, magnesium and other elements. The Stardust sample is primarily magnesium. Along with olivine, the dust from Wild 2 contains high-temperature minerals rich in calcium, aluminum and titanium.


            Naturally, like all new findings, this one comes as no surprise to the exploded planet hypothesis. The EPH maintains comets and asteroids started out physically and chemically the same – fragments of exploded planets or moons. It is therefore to be expected that they contain elements requiring high formation temperatures such as those found in Earth’s mantle. The new ad hoc patch to the mainstream model to accommodate these findings is that the early Sun must have ejected hot material to great distances that subsequently became incorporated into comets. How that material managed to form olivine, which requires high pressure as well as high temperature, is not yet addressed. But we can be sure that inventive theoreticians will not be stumped for long.


Numerous TNOs indicated beyond 100 au

We have long maintained that the Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) were the remnants of two exploded planets, not just one; and that an outer belt of these objects would eventually be discovered to show that the two or three objects presently known are not just strays or flukes. Now comes new evidence to that effect in AJ 132:819-822 (2006). The first detection of 100-meter-size objects by the method of serendipitous stellar occultation produced three findings. This method consists of recording the diffraction shadow created when an object crosses the observer’s line of sight and occults the disk of a background star. One of these three detections is most consistent with an object between Saturn and Uranus. The two other diffractions patterns detected are caused by TNOs beyond 100 AU from the Sun and hence are the farthest objects heretofore detected in the solar system. These detections show that the TNO asteroid belt is much more extended than previously known, and that relatively small objects are present there as well. This finding gives critical clues to understanding solar system structure and formation.


###

 

 Response to ‘BELIEVING IS SEEING’: I prefer, ‘Do not look into laser with remaining eye.’ – Gordon D. Pusch



  Home|TOC|Previous|Next